MysticMag contains reviews that were written by our experts and follow the strict reviewing standards, including ethical standards, that we have adopted. Such standards require that each review will be based on an independent, honest and professional examination of the reviewer. That being said, we may earn a commission when a user completes an action using our links, which will however not affect the review but might affect the rankings. The latter are determined on the basis of customer satisfaction of previous sales and compensation received. We do not rank our recommended psychic reading websites on their host psychic practitioner's ability to predict the future.
Written by Xeandra Naicker | Updated On November 29, 2022

Real Psychic or Fake? How to Spot the Difference (2022 Guide)

Real Psychic or Fake? How to Spot the Difference (2022 Guide)

Whether you’re a long-time believer or getting ready for your first reading, you need to know that you can trust your psychic. But in a world where scam artists are all too common, how can you tell the difference between real psychics and those looking to rip you off?

Since biblical times (and even earlier), people have turned to psychics for answers from the spirit world. Unfortunately, fake psychics have been scamming people for almost as long. It’s pretty much impossible to assess whether or not the person you’re talking to is a legitimately gifted reader, or just another con artist hoping to make a quick dollar.

I’ve tested many of them, and if you don’t want to make a mistake when choosing one, go to Keen’s website to find the most accurate readers. It even comes with a satisfaction guarantee, so you can get a refund on your reading if you aren’t satisfied.

Find a Real Psychic

8 Ways to Spot Fake Psychics Online

1. They Have Bad Reviews

Whenever you finish a reading with a psychic, you’re given the chance to write a review. This isn’t for the psychic’s ego. Reviews help potential clients like you figure out if the advisor in question is legit.

Look out for reviews saying things like:

  • They seemed to take a very long time to answer my questions.
  • Their advice didn’t resonate with me at all.
  • It felt like they were guessing, not reading.
  • They were just telling me what I wanted to hear.

If you’re paying for your reading by the minute, a psychic who seems to drag out their answers might be trying to get more money out of you. Real psychics with true gifts will understand what you’re looking for. They’ll ask questions to make sure they understand where you’re coming from, making them far more likely to give you advice that’s relevant.

Look out for highly-rated psychics with good written reviews. These readers are far less likely to be fake. Here is a list of the top 10 psychic reading sites recommended by MysticMag.

2. Their Platform Doesn’t Have a Good Reputation

There are tons of psychic sites and phone lines out there, and some of them are filled with fakes. Legitimate sites are much more likely to host or employ legitimate psychics. Make sure the platform your psychic is using has a good reputation and is owned by a registered company.

3. Their Profile Is Incomplete

Good psychic sites insist that their advisors create profiles that detail their experience, skills, tools, and reading style. Legitimate psychics will be open about the tools they use, the psychics they’ve studied with, and the topics they feel confident advising you on. A complete profile is a good indication that you can trust the psychic who wrote it.

Even if you follow the advice above before starting a reading, you might still end up with a fake psychic. Remember, the best psychic reading sites come with satisfaction guarantees so you can claim your money back if you think your psychic is a fake.

4. They’re Being Vague

Real psychics use a combination of psychic gifts, mediumship, and intuition to answer your questions and guide you. They ask relevant questions and use your answers to offer advice that’s specific to your situation.

If the psychic you’re talking to is being vague, chances are they’re faking it. They might even be using cold reading tactics. This is when someone offers generic snippets of information in the hope you might connect your real situation with their fake readings. Vague readings that don’t really sit right with you are almost definitely fake.

If you want to get an idea of what a psychic is like before you pay for a full reading, I recommend using the free minutes offered by sites like Keen Psychics.

5. They’re Asking a Lot of Questions

Fake psychics don’t have real gifts to help them sense what’s going on in your life, and they lack the intuition needed to understand your questions. If your psychic is asking a lot of questions, they probably don’t have extra senses guiding them.

Too many questions almost always indicate that a fake psychic is trying to make you say the things you want to hear. They then parrot your answers back to you. This makes them sound legit, even when they’re not. Asking lots of questions pretty much guarantees that they’re a fraud.

6. They’re Manipulating You

If the questions you’re being asked feel manipulative, they probably are. Fake psychics will try to control the narrative and lead you to the conclusion they’ve decided you should reach.

In contrast, real psychics help you explore the energy and forces impacting you and your life, and guide you through possible outcomes and choices. Legitimate psychics never manipulate vulnerable people.

7. They’re Not Listening

Fake psychics talk… a lot. Instead of letting you talk and responding to your questions, they fill your head — and the session you’re paying for — with stories about themselves, dire predictions, and made-up situations designed to trick you into trusting them. It’s all part of their smoke-and-mirrors deception: if you can’t talk, they can’t misread you or give you bad advice.

Real psychics create space for you to talk and explore your feelings. They are far more interested in using their gifts to help you than in talking about themselves.

8. They’re Giving Definite Answers

Psychics use their gifts to read energy and sense things outside of the normal human realm. They share their insights to help seekers find clarity and purpose. This gives you the opportunity to change direction and head down a new path. Real psychics know that people have agency and choice and that the future cannot be predetermined or predicted.

Fake psychics have no problem telling your future, regardless of what they think it might hold. If your psychic tells you that something will definitely happen, you’re probably talking to a fake.

Bottom Line

These outlines should put you on the right path to determining whether you are dealing with a fake psychic who is trying to take advantage of you.

Now that you know how to spot real psychics, here is a list of some of the most trustworthy psychics from top sites.

Find a Real Psychic

About the author
Xeandra has been drawn to all things spiritual and divine from a young age. She spends a lot of time meditating and her real life experiences have given her special insights in understanding the power of the universe.